What is PragmaGism?

PragmaGism (pragmaTism + maGic, also written pragmagism) is a philosophical position that starts from the pragmatism of William James and recommends magic as a rival to blind, mechanical causality. It is offered as an aid to the re-enchantment of a world that is often said to have become disenchanted. The term was coined by Ian Halloran in “PragmaTism + Magic = PragmaGism”, published in Volume 1 of The Journal of Sophistry on December 22, 2021. The capitals mark the letter that changes: pragmaTism becomes pragmaGism.

The formula

The pragmaTism of “The Will to Believe”
+ Created truths as !natural
+ A dash of occasionalism (optional)
= PragmaGism

The pragmatism

PragmaGism begins where American pragmatism begins. We are an evolved and evolving species, and nothing suggests our minds have reached a form that can grasp the true nature of things. Our picture of the world is always particular, contingent, and probabilistic, and we never encounter certainty in nature. The originary pragmatists, Charles Sanders Peirce and William James, took this from Darwin and Kant, and concluded that every belief is a bet: what you really believe is what you are ready to act on and risk something for. The short version: it’s working hypotheses all the way down. You will never find the bottom, so better move on.

The particular pragmatism in PragmaGism is that of James’s 1896 essay “The Will to Believe.” James argues that some questions, such as faith versus skepticism, cannot be settled by evidence or reason. For these intellectually irresolvable options, our passional, willing nature has the right to decide, and waiting costs us something. James also notices that, in some cases, “faith in a fact can help create the fact.” PragmaGism accepts James’s starting point but recommends magic instead of a traditional faith.

The magic

The working definition: magic is an irreducible and !natural causal force that is willed or intended. Stage magic works as an analogy, but it is not what is meant. “!natural” borrows the “not” operator from programming and stands in for supernatural, which simply means beyond nature, without the assumption that it must be false or fantasy. “Irreducible” means it is the explanatory bottom, at least for us: magic cannot be explained away, just as mechanical causality cannot be explained away.

Created truths

The claim is that magic is common and ordinary. Whenever an intending mind brings about something that would not exist by nature alone, it creates a truth, and that truth is !natural. The ancient Greeks contrasted phusis (nature, how things behave on their own) with two things that are not nature, and those two supply the first examples:

  • TechnĂȘ (skill, craft): Aristotle’s contrast. A cabinet doesn’t grow from wood; its origin is in the maker. A scholar’s rock or Duchamp’s Fountain becomes art without any physical change at all.
  • Nomos (law, custom, convention): the Sophists’ contrast. Nothing physically detectable about a phone makes it someone’s property, and no instrument can detect that a player belongs to this particular team.
  • Willed truths: James’s cases, where the will helps make something true. A love that comes about because you pursued it, or passengers who stop a train robbery because each trusts the others to act.
  • Information: a pebble in the wild means nothing; a pebble added to a pile for each sheep let into the pen is a count. The meaning comes from intention, not from the pebble.

None of these is the kind of thing a physicist can point a sensor at. They are created by intending minds, and they are a different order of thing from physical and biological processes.

A dash of occasionalism

An optional add-on. Occasionalism is the old view that God is the intervening cause between events, either for a few miracles or for every causal instant. In its magical form, it means seeing the flux of becoming as meaningful and miraculous rather than as stuff that just happens. It restores some necessity to a picture that has looked increasingly accidental for a thousand years. Magic here is not meant to replace God; it is consistent with God or Gods.

Why magic

The article floats a few ideas. Magic is a humble middle ground between traditional religion and blind mechanical forces, and an easier way in for people who fit neither. It is better for getting what you want in the affairs of living than fabled ideals like God, determinism, or certainty. And a passional faith in magic engenders will and effort, where determinism does not inspire. Or, as Volume 1 ends: if it doesn’t work, it’s not magic.

Read more

The full statement of the position is Volume 1, free to read online. Pragmatism Week introduces pragmatism one idea a day, and shorter pieces are in the JoS Annex.

How to cite

Halloran, Ian. “PragmaTism + Magic = PragmaGism.” The Journal of Sophistry 1 (2021). ISSN 3144-9565 (print), 3144-9573 (online). https://thejournalofsophistry.com/vol1/PragmaGism.html